Directed by the legendary Martin Scorsese, who having
already made such classics as Raging Bull, Taxi Driver, Goodfellas, Casino and The
Departed, returns to the world of the mob for possibly one last hurrah.
The film is based on the confessions, late in life, of Frank
‘The Irishman’ Sheeran, a real-life mobster, which lawyer Charles Brandt documented
in his 2004 book ‘I Heard You Paint Houses’.
Sheeran was a truck driver who started to make some money
illegally on the side. When he is found out his union’s lawyer Bill Bufalino
(Ray Romano) helps him out. The price for this seems to be further involvement
in the crime underworld and Bufalino introduces him to his cousin Russell (Joe
Pesci), the head of the local mafia. Sheeran’s
Second World War training seems to make him very good at following orders without
asking any difficult questions nor developing any feelings or morality, making
him an ideal candidate to do the mob’s dirty work for them.
Russell Bufalino then recommends him to Jimmy Hoffa (Al
Pacino), the head of America’s most powerful and corrupt union, where he ends
up working for Hoffa as chief bodyguard and hitman. Hoffa grows to trust him
completely and becomes close to his family, especially his daughter Peggy (Anna
Paquin), who we see become increasingly disillusioned with her father as the
years tick by.
After John F. Kennedy comes to power in 1960 the Government
sets out to get Hoffa and eventually they send him to jail. Once he has served
his time, Hoffa tries to once again retake power at the top of the union but
this doesn’t go down well with the rest of the crime fraternity.
It is on the 1975 road trip to the wedding of Bill's
daughter that Sheeran learns that he must kill Hoffa. Then in a clandestine
journey that involves two flights and four car rides, he meets up with Hoffa
and matter-of-factly shoots him twice in the back of the head. Then he has to
call Hoffa’s widow Jo (Welker White) to reassure her that her missing husband
would be sure to turn up sooner or later. A phone call that he is clearly still
haunted by 28 years later although perhaps not so much by the actual killing.
Apparently Netflix handed over an obscene amount of money to
Scorsese to fund this film and in many ways he delivers for them but perhaps
Netflix gave him too much of a free hand and should have insisted on a bit more
editing as it seems overlong.
Clocking in at a massive three-and-a-half hours, the
overused word ‘epic’ has been uttered by many but there isn't actually that much
going on a lot of the time and there are a lot of characters in the film,
probably too many. These are often introduced with captions giving their names
with how and when they died. These are usual violent deaths but actually, for
Scorsese, quite dull deaths.
Sure, it's well made film and fascinating at times but it is
slower and more labyrinthine than his previous films while not being not half as entertaining or enthralling
as say Goodfellas or Casino were.
Scorsese reunites Robert De Niro and Joe Pesci for the first time since Casino and chooses to digitally de-age them rather than hire younger actors for the earlier scenes of a film that spans six decades. Does it work? It’s debatable.
It is an ambitious project but feels like one film too
far for Scorsese but if he gets one last Oscar will anyone really mind? Not
sure he’ll get it though.